Skip to main content

The American with the Dragon Tattoo

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011, David Fincher) review


The American with the Dragon Tattoo

I just have to say, wow. Contender for best film I’ve seen all year. ( Although this is only second cinema outing all year….)



Ok, I know this is blasphemy considering I’m a Film Studies University student but I haven’t seen or read any of the original Milennium Trilogy films or books. So this review is based on Fincher’s film as being stand alone, without comparison to the original and without getting into the debate of it being a ‘pointless remake’ which, apart from the English language, is too similar to the original. However one thing that annoyed me throughout the film is the nationalities. I found it hard to keep up with what nationality the main characters were supposed to be, due to it being set in Sweden but all of the characters, including a Mikael Blomkvist having a perfect American accent.

Barring a very bond-esque title sequence (I wish more movies had these) this was a pretty slow film to start. We’re introduced to a whole bunch of boring people and Daniel Craig’s expressionless face doesn’t do much to draw us in. You know the crazy, p@£%ing annoying people who sit in front of you in cinemas who talk through the entire thing, swinging back and forward in their chairs? Well I had the godfather of those knobs in front of me and for the first half hour I just imagined smashing a bottle over his head. Then the film picked up, a lot, and by the 45 min mark my anger for that git had disappeared and I was totally engaged with the film. So much so that the only other time I thought about the moron was at the end when he stumbled his way out.

While not the most fascinating plot or fantastic locations or relatable characters, this just felt like the most intriguing and engaging film I’ve seen in yonks, possibly for those reasons. For a start the sounds were outstanding, with constant background noises and an eery score keeping things tense and flowing quickly, hardly allowing time for brain pit-stops. They lead you to believe that a train, or even a door could be dangerous. The make up and style of Lisabeth is incredible, with her white face and eyebrows giving her a ghost like appearance, making it difficult to determine gender or age, while her numerous piercings keep her fascinating and intriguing to look at. The acting of Rooney Mara is incredibly difficult to fault, as she really sells the damaged, genius, social outcast. Nice to see her nominated for an Oscar, one of the few who deserve it. Even Daniel ‘as predictable as Hugh Grant’ Craig’s performance won me over in the end. As the plot moved on from the fairly boring first third we actually began to see multiple facial expressions of Daniel Craig, including some genuinely funny humour in relatable situations such as when he simply calls “Cat” for the unknown cat. Also Fincher absolutely made the right choice to include the controversial scenes (no spoilers here), as they really give an insight into why Lisabeth is the way she is, with obviously the visual representation much stronger than simply implying the actions.



Trying to think of things to fault is fairly difficult, although there were a few things that I wasn’t overly fussed on. At times I couldn’t keep up with the plot due to the sheer amount of characters and names thrown about- I mean seriously, how big is the suspect’s family?! Also some of the camera movements were a bit distracting. Where I loved how close ups were often used on Lisabeth to show off her features and make her just look really unusual, sometimes it went too far such as one shot where the camera tracks behind her and ends up being a close up, but she’s upside down, which is a bit disengaging. Only other thing I can think of is that I will never be able to watch this film with my parents, thanks to a lot of boobies and naughty parts.




Overall I was surprised with how much I enjoyed the film. Like I said I’m judging it as a stand-alone and not comparing with the Swedish trilogy. I think that Rooney Mara should be a strong contender at the Oscars for best actress and the film absolutely deserves its nominations for best sound editing and sound mixing.


Recommended, just don’t bring parents/grandparents/people who support Liverpool (for obvious reasons).


Verdict: 4.1/5


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Scottscars 2023

    The 2023 Scottscars For the film industry, 2023 was a year of soaring highs, particularly in animation, as well as crippling strains- see the SAG-AFTA strike or the state of Marvel and DC. So grab yourself a Venti Iced Skinny Hazelnut Macchiato, with sugar free syrup and enjoy the 2023 Scottscars- the awards they all want to win, they just don't know it yet. The running order as always: The 2023 Scottsars Awards Last years predictions 2024 movie predictions My 2023 Stats Because the Scottscars are 100% my personal opinion, here’s what we’re working with! I had a very busy year doing the festival circuit across the world for my own short animated film, Candlelight , so I didn't see as much as usual in terms of feature films- although I have watched 75,348 short films this year. Movies watched: 72 Cinema : 29 times, 11 Imax Most watched actor/actress:  Jackie Chan Most Watched Director: Brett Ratner (oh dear 💀) Notable films I haven’t seen this year:  Tar Maestro The Boy an

The 2022 Scottscars

  The 2022 Scottscars Hello readers! Hope you’re both well. 2022 was a funny old year in the movies. There’s certainly a sense of Hollywood trying to find its place in the new post-covid landscape, to varying success. Disney’s MCU experiments had mixed results, with the Disney plus shows varying wildly in quality and Thor 4 being an attempt to make a film about cancer into a stand up comedy routine.  The year started with Will Smith’s slapping Oscars performance, then the world heard about Amber Heard’s dog stepping on a bee, Ezra Miller continued to be the absolute worst, Henry Cavill being in and out and all about with the Witcher and Superman, Warner Brothers showing absolutely zero confidence in their products by shelving 2 COMPLETED movies and James Gunn deciding to toss out the entire DC universe and rebooting it from scratch. But one thing that DOESN’T change is the most obscure and least renowned film awards of the year (It’s tradition now, so we're stuck with it). Welcome

Guess the Sketch!

So I've decided that my artwork's went waaaay downhill since I moved to digital sketching and inking. I still prefer digital for non messy colouring but for sketching, nothing beats a good ol' pencil. So for my first serious pencil sketch since my Sherlock Holmes sketch back in about 2008 I decided to sketch ......... Why don't you guess? Here's my first initial outlines, which to be honest looks like a troll in drag. Anyone who guesses right before I update the post with my progress can pick what I draw next! That's right people- FREE COMMISSION! Post your guesses here on the blog if you have a googlemail/gmail account or in the link on my facebook Dear, dear I've got my work cut out for me